top 5 best roasted pecans on amazon
Shutt’s Nuts purchased and reviewed some of the bestselling roasted pecans and Amazon. The Result? The BEST REVIEW of ROASTED PECANS on Amazon.
amazon roasted pecans
review summary
The summary of the Shutt’s Nuts Amazon Roasted Pecans Review is below.
We really bought the pecans, opened them, and tasted them. This review by Shutt’s Nuts is completely honest and unbiased.
Scroll down for videos and full scoring.
#1: we talk nuts
Why We Like Them:
Best taste
Why We Don’t:
Second most expensive of tested.
Read the Amazon Reviews for We Talk Nuts Pecans
#2: Oh! Nuts
Why We Like Them:
They come in these awesome individual packs
Why We Don’t:
Not quite as much flavor as We Talk Nuts
Read the Amazon Review for OH! Nuts Pecans
#3: we got nuts
Why We Like Them:
Huge nuts!
Why We Don’t:
Some Amazon customers received stale or even rancid nuts.
Read the Amazon Reviews for We Got Nuts Pecans
#4 Planters
Why we like them:
Price and consistency
Why we don’t:
They’re smaller than the others
Read the Amazon Reviews for Planters Pecans
#5: front porch nuts
Why we like them:
Good price. Decent size and flavor.
Why we don’t:
So much salt you can’t really taste the nut. Highest priced roasted pecans tested.
Read the Amazon Reviews for Front Porch Pecans
Amazon Roasted Pecans Video Review
Check out the in-depth video review of the Amazon Pecans below. . .
THEN check out the break-down of how all the Amazon nuts scored.
The Best Roasted pecans on amazon
Full review scores below
We Talk Nuts
Total86.1
- Taste: 28 out of 30. Has that quintessential butter taste we love in pecans. Not bitterness whatsoever.
- Customer Reviews: 18.1 out of 20. Amazon reviewers give these a great 4.7 stars on average!
- Value: 8 out of 15. Price at review was the most expensive of those tested but still better than some grocery store prices for fancy pecans at $1.25 / ounce.
- Nutrition: 15 out of 15. Just two ingredients: Pecans and Himalayan salt.
- Size: 9 out of 10. Largest of those reviewed.
- Packaging: 5 out of 8. We're not fans of these large 2-pound bags with re-sealable seals that never seem to work right.
- Origin: 1 out of 2. Their website mentions Georgia pecans only, and they tout "farm fresh" everywhere, so we'll give them the benefit of the doubt.
OH! Nuts
Total79.2
- Taste: 25 out of 30. A little more "roasted" taste than the others, slightly more bitterness than the top-tasting.
- Customer Reviews: 19.2 out of 20. Amazon reviewers give these a near-perfect 4.8 stars!
- Value: 11 out of 15. Price at review was a good $0.86 / ounce.
- Nutrition: 12 out of 15. Roasted in cottonseed oil. Only negative is that they're roasted in iodized salt instead of sea salt.
- Size: 7 out of 10. Smallest of those reviewed.
- Packaging: 5 out of 8. We're not fans of these large 2-pound bags with re-sealable seals that never seem to work right.
- Origin: 0 out of 2. No origin given on OH! Nuts website or on Amazon.
We Got Nuts
Total78.4
- Taste: 23 out of 30. The good bags are good but the bad bags are bad. Some bags are stale or even rancid. The bag we reviewed tied for best in the test.
- Customer Reviews: 16.4 out of 20. Amazon reviewers give thesethe lowest score we tested. This is due to a large number of 1-star reviews.
- Value: 12 out of 15. Price at review was good at $0.84 / ounce.
- Nutrition: 12 out of 15. Just two ingredients: Pecans and salt. We presume it’s not fancy Himalayan salt or sea salt.
- Size: 8 out of 10. Second largest of those reviewed.
- Packaging: 5 out of 8. We’re not fans of these large 2-pound bags with re-sealable seals that never seem to work right.
- Origin: 2 out of 2. Website states “product of the USA”
Planters
Total77.4
- Taste: 23 out of 30. These don’t have as much of that buttery pecan flavor we love. However, the size is perfectly consistent and there is no bitterness.
- Customer Reviews: 18.4 out of 20. Amazon reviewers give these a very good 4.6 out of 5 stars.
- Value: 13 out of 15. Price at review was a good $0.82 / ounce. Lowest cost of those tested, but there are still less expensive options on Amazon.
- Nutrition: 11 out of 15. Roasted in peanut oil. They’re roasted in iodized salt instead of sea salt.
- Size: 5 out of 10. Smallest of those reviewed.
- Packaging: 6 out of 8. We like the small can. We think the hard packaging helped keep the nuts from breaking into small pieces during shipping.
- Origin: 1 out of 2. Grown in North America (America and Mexico)
Front Porch Pecans
Total 69
- Taste: 18 out of 30. These nuts might taste great, but we’ll never know because of all that salt! These nuts are too salty.
- Customer Reviews: 18 out of 20. Amazon reviewers give these pecans 4 out of 5 stars.
- Value: 5 out of 15. Price at review was a good $1.44 / ounce. The most expensive tested.
- Nutrition: 12 out of 15. Roasted in peanut oil and salted with seal salt.
- Size: 9 out of 10. Largest of those reviewed, but there were quite a few pieces.
- Packaging: 5 out of 8. Typical resealable packs. We like that they’re smaller than the mammoth 2-pound sacks.
- Origin: 2 out of 2. Grown on their family farm in Georgia!